Three questions for the advocates
Stephen Kirchner wrote last week about the Greenspan rule and the RBA, building on a post by Lars Christensen. I could only read the teaser from Kirchner, but the rule is built on nominal GDP targeting: the target is the inflation target plus an assumed trend growth rate. The exchange that followed on X sharpened my earlier view.
nGDP targeting comes in two flavours. Some argue the level of nominal GDP is what should be targeted: set a path, and return to it after any miss. Others argue for the growth rate, and let past misses go. Most academic advocates prefer the level. The Greenspan rule is a growth rule.
Advocates promise that an nGDP target protects jobs better than an inflation target, and that it leaves the central bank with less discretion. They also present it as the simpler regime. So there are three questions. Does it protect jobs? Does it reduce discretion? Is it simpler? I am not convinced.



